A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder – Gateway Playhouse – Theatre Review

Gail Bennett, Blake Price & Kelley Dorney. Photo by Jeff Bellante.

By Kristen Weyer.

Nothing goes together like music, mayhem and…murder? A deadly good time awaits at the Gateway Playhouse’s production of A Gentleman’s Guide to Love & Murder.  With book and lyrics by Robert L. Freedman and music and lyrics by Steven Lutvak, this zany musical is based on a novel by Roy Horniman. Directed and choreographed here by Peggy Hickey, with associate direction and choreography by Richard Bulda.

This macabre musical follows the murderous escapades of Monty Navarro, excellently portrayed by Blake Price. As the play opens it is 1909, and we meet Monty, grieving for his recently departed Mother, who he quickly discovers was actually a disinherited member of the illustrious D’Ysquith family. After learning of her horrible treatment at their hands, and that only eight members of the family stand between him and the Earldom, he decides the best revenge for his mother would be to take his place as the Earl of Highhurst. So naturally, he begins to systematically murder his way up the succession. Add in a couple love interests, some crazy complications, and a multitude of musical numbers and you have a fabulous, if lethal, situation.

James Taylor Odom and Company. Photo by Jeff Bellante.

The cast brings out all the fun and ridiculousness to be enjoyed in this entertaining musical. From the leads, to the ensemble the talent is obvious. Excellent vocals, and comedic timing abound. Sultry Sibella is stunningly played by Gail Bennett, and the sweet Phoebe is perfectly portrayed by Kelley Dorney. Blake Price impresses as Monty with his strong vocals, amusing expressions, and his charming air which gets you to root for the murderer. Let us not forget to mention the impressive performance of James Taylor Odom who portrays the D’Ysquith Family.  Yes, you read that correctly, ALL eight people between Monty and the Earldom are portrayed by Odom.  He switches from one character to the next with remarkable speed, and a couple crazy quick changes.  Each character is given their own personality and accent, and he does a marvelous job in personifying them all differently. 

The costumes in this production are simply stunning.  Based on the original costume design by Linda Cho, gorgeous fabrics and colors are crafted in truly beautiful historical pieces. The set as well is genuinely impressive and is also based on the original scenic design of Alexander Dodge. As always, the orchestra never fails to impress and is under direction from Charlie Reuter.

This madcap murder musicale is a rollicking fun time.  If you’re looking for an entertaining suspension of reality for a couple of hours, then look no further than the Gateway Playhouse and A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder.

A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder will be playing at The Gateway Playhouse until December 4th. For tickets and current entrance requirements click here.